The AVOID Act's compressed deadlines mean you'll be leaning on your subcontracts harder and faster than ever before. Weak indemnification language or missing insurance provisions won't just be inconvenient — they'll be expensive.
For years, New York general contractors could manage subcontract deficiencies reactively. If an indemnification clause was ambiguous, you'd negotiate it in litigation. If a subcontractor's insurance lapsed, you'd deal with it when the claim came in. The timeline was forgiving enough that gaps could be patched mid-case.
The AVOID Act ends that approach. When you have 60 days from your answer to file third-party claims, there is no time to discover that your subcontract's indemnification provision is unenforceable or that the sub's additional insured endorsement was never issued. You need your contracts to be right before the complaint arrives.
The following checklist covers the provisions that directly affect your ability to file timely, enforceable third-party claims under the new law. Use it to audit your current standard subcontract form and any active project agreements.
Your indemnification language must be broad enough to cover Labor Law §240 and §241 claims but must not require the subcontractor to indemnify you for your own sole negligence — New York courts will void clauses that do. Review every active subcontract for this balance.
At minimum, subcontractors should carry $1M per occurrence / $2M aggregate GL coverage. On larger projects, require $2M/$4M. Umbrella or excess coverage of at least $5M is standard on most commercial jobs. These limits need to be specified in writing, not assumed.
The subcontractor's policy must name you as an additional insured — not just on the certificate, but via an actual endorsement on the policy. The ISO CG 20 10 and CG 20 37 endorsements (for ongoing and completed operations) are the standard. Certificates alone are not enough.
Without this, the subcontractor's insurer can argue that your policy should share the loss. Your subcontract must require that the sub's coverage is primary and non-contributory with respect to your additional insured status. This must also appear in the endorsement, not just the contract.
The sub's insurer must waive its right to subrogate against you. Without a Waiver of Subrogation endorsement, the sub's carrier can reimburse the sub and then come after you for recovery — which defeats the purpose of the indemnity chain entirely.
Your contract should require the subcontractor to provide at least 30 days' advance notice if their policy is cancelled or not renewed. Under the AVOID Act, discovering a lapsed policy at the 60-day deadline is a crisis. Build in the early warning. See our full breakdown of insurance gaps the AVOID Act will expose.
Many Labor Law claims are filed years after the work is done. Your subcontract should require the sub to maintain completed operations coverage for at least three years after project completion — and require documentation that it was maintained.
The sub's GL policy should include contractual liability coverage, which covers the indemnification obligations the sub assumed under your subcontract. Without it, the sub's insurer may deny coverage for the very indemnity claim you're relying on.
There is a significant difference between a duty to indemnify (reimburse after the fact) and a duty to defend (pay defense costs as they accrue). Your subcontract should require both. A duty to defend triggers at the onset of litigation, which is exactly when you need cost relief.
Your contract should give you the right to request updated certificates at any time during the project and for the duration of completed operations coverage. Passive certificate collection at contract execution is not enough under the AVOID Act's timeline demands.
This point deserves emphasis because it's one of the most common — and costly — misunderstandings in construction risk management. A certificate of insurance is not a policy. It is not an endorsement. It is not binding on the insurer.
A COI can state that a subcontractor carries $2M in coverage and names you as additional insured, and the insurer can still deny your tender if the actual policy language doesn't support it. Under the AVOID Act, you may have 60 days to file a third-party claim, but if the sub's insurer denies coverage, you're in coverage litigation — which takes years and costs money you shouldn't have had to spend.
For active projects with significant Labor Law exposure: Request copies of the actual endorsements from your subcontractors' insurers — not just certificates. The difference between a COI and a properly issued endorsement is often the difference between a covered and a denied claim.
A common question is whether existing subcontracts can be amended to add missing provisions. The answer is yes — but it requires the subcontractor's agreement, which is easier to obtain on active projects with ongoing payment than on completed work.
For projects underway, prioritize:
The fundamental shift: Before the AVOID Act, contract deficiencies were a negotiation problem. After April 18, they're a deadline problem. There's a meaningful difference between fixing an indemnity clause over several weeks of back-and-forth and needing an enforceable third-party claim ready in 60 days.
We audit subcontractor agreement language for New York GCs and identify the provisions most likely to create problems under the AVOID Act's compressed timeline.
Get a Free Consultation